Comparison BMW X1 (E84) 28i (258 Hp) xDrive & Volkswagen Golf III Variant (1HX0) 1.8 Syncro (90 Hp) & Mercedes-Benz S-class Long (W221) AMG S 63 (525 HP)
Add car |
Remove car |
Remove car |
Remove car |
| Brand: | BMW | Volkswagen | Mercedes-Benz |
| Model: | X1 | Golf | S-class |
| Generation: | X1 (E84) | Golf III Variant (1HX0) | S-class Long (W221) |
| Engine / modification: | 28i (258 Hp) xDrive | 1.8 Syncro (90 Hp) | AMG S 63 (525 HP) |
| Production start: | 2009 year | 1994 year | 2006 year |
| Production end: | 2011 year | 1999 year | 2013 year |
| Coupe type: | Crossover | Combi | Sedan |
| Num. of Doors: | 5 | 5 | 4 |
| Num. of seats: | 5 | 5 | 4 |
| Fuel consumption / economy - urban: | 23.1 l/100 km | ||
| Fuel consumption / economy - extra urban: | 10 l/100 km | ||
| Fuel consumption / economy - combined: | 9.4 l/100 km | 8.8 l/100 km | 15 l/100 km |
| Fuel Type: | Petrol (Gasoline) | Petrol (Gasoline) | Petrol (Gasoline) |
| Fuel tank volume: | 65 l | 90 l | |
| Emission standard: | Euro 5 | EURO IV | |
| Power: | 258 hp | 90 hp | 525 hp |
| Max power in: | 6600 rpm. | 5500 rpm. | 6800 rpm. |
| Maximum speed: | 230 km/h | 172 km/h | 250 km/h |
| Acceleration from 0 to 100 km/h: | 14 sec | 4.6 sec | |
| Torque: | 300 Nm @ 2500 rpm. | 145 Nm/2500 rpm. | 630 Nm |
| Model Engine: | N52B30 | M 156.984 | |
| Engine position: | Front, longitudinal | Front, transverse | Front, longitudinal |
| Engine displacement: | 2996 cm3 | 1781 cm3 | 6208 cm3 |
| Engine oil capacity: | 6.5 l | ||
| Fuel System: | Multi-point injection | Mono-point injection | Multi-point injection |
| Position of cylinders: | Inline | Inline | V engine |
| Valvetrain: | OHC | dohc | |
| Number of cylinders: | 6 | 4 | 8 |
| Number of valves per cylinder: | 4 | 2 | 4 |
| Compression ratio: | 10.7 | 10 | 11.3 |
| Piston Stroke: | 88 mm | 86.4 mm | 94.6 mm |
| Cylinder Bore: | 85 mm | 81 mm | 102.2 mm |
| Wheel Drive: | All wheel drive (4x4) | All wheel drive (4x4) | Rear wheel drive |
| Number of Gears (automatic transmission): | 6 | - | 7 |
| Number of Gears (manual transmission): | 5 | ||
| Length: | 4457 mm | 4340 mm | 5206 mm |
| Width: | 1789 mm | 1695 mm | 1871 mm |
| Height: | 1535 mm | 1430 mm | 1473 mm |
| Wheelbase: | 2475 mm | 3165 mm | |
| Front track: | 1478 mm | 1604 mm | |
| Rear (Back) track: | 1460 mm | 1606 mm | |
| Minimum volume of Luggage (trunk): | 420 l | 340 l | |
| Maximum amount of Luggage (trunk): | 1350 l | 1300 l | 560 l |
| Front suspension: | Wishbone | Pneumatic elastic element | |
| Rear suspension: | Suspension with traction connecting levers | Pneumatic elastic element | |
| Max weight: | 1775 kg | 2705 kg | |
| Front brakes: | Ventilated discs | Disc | Ventilated discs |
| Rear brakes: | Drum | Ventilated discs | |
| Kerb Weight: | 1350 kg | 2180 kg | |
| ABS: | yes | yes | yes |
| Steering type: | Steering rack and pinion | ||
| Power steering: | Hydraulic Steering | ||
| Minimum turning circle (turning diameter): | 12 m | ||
| Tire size: | 195/60 R14 | 255/40R19; 275/40R19 |