Comparison BMW 1 Series Hatchback 5dr (E87 LCI, facelift 2007) 123d (204 Hp) & Kia Carnival I (UP/GQ) 2.5i V6 24V (165 Hp) & Dacia Logan I MCV (facelift 2008) 1.5 dCi (88 Hp) FAP 7 Seats & Nissan X-Trail III (T32; facelift 2017) 1.6 dCi (130 Hp) Xtronic & Porsche Cayman (981c) 2.7 (275 Hp) PDK & Mercedes-Benz S-class (W221, facelift 2009) S 500 V8 (388 Hp) G-TRONIC
Remove car |
Remove car |
Remove car |
Remove car |
Remove car |
Remove car |
|
| Brand: | BMW | Kia | Dacia | Nissan | Porsche | Mercedes-Benz |
| Model: | 1 Series | Carnival | Logan | X-Trail | Cayman | S-class |
| Generation: | 1 Series Hatchback 5dr (E87 LCI, facelift 2007) | Carnival I (UP/GQ) | Logan I MCV (facelift 2008) | X-Trail III (T32; facelift 2017) | Cayman (981c) | S-class (W221, facelift 2009) |
| Engine / modification: | 123d (204 Hp) | 2.5i V6 24V (165 Hp) | 1.5 dCi (88 Hp) FAP 7 Seats | 1.6 dCi (130 Hp) Xtronic | 2.7 (275 Hp) PDK | S 500 V8 (388 Hp) G-TRONIC |
| Production start: | 2007 year | 1999 year | 2010 year | 2017 year | 2013 year | 2009 year |
| Production end: | 2011 year | 2001 year | 2013 year | 2018 year | 2011 year | |
| Coupe type: | Hatchback | Minivan | SUV | Coupe | Sedan | |
| Powertrain Architecture: | Internal Combustion engine | |||||
| Num. of Doors: | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 2 | 4 |
| Num. of seats: | 5 | 7 | 7 | 5 | 2 | 5 |
| Fuel consumption / economy - urban: | 6.5 l/100 km | 5.8-6.0 l/100 km | 10.9 l/100 km | 16.5-16.7 l/100 km | ||
| Fuel consumption / economy - extra urban: | 4.4 l/100 km | 4.7-4.9 l/100 km | 6.2 l/100 km | 7.9-8.1 l/100 km | ||
| Fuel consumption / economy - combined: | 5.2 l/100 km | 11.3 l/100 km | 5.1-5.3 l/100 km | 7.9 l/100 km | 11-11.2 l/100 km | |
| Fuel Type: | Diesel | Petrol (Gasoline) | Diesel | Diesel | Petrol (Gasoline) | Petrol (Gasoline) |
| Drag coefficient: | 0.36 | |||||
| Fuel tank volume: | 51 l | 75 l | 50 l | 60 l | 64 l | 90 l |
| Emission standard: | Euro 5 | Euro 5 | Euro 6 b | |||
| CO2 emissions: | 138 g/km | 135-139 g/km | 183 g/km | 258-262 g/km | ||
| Power: | 204 hp | 165 hp | 88 hp | 130 hp | 275 hp | 388 hp |
| Max power in: | 4400 rpm. | 6500 rpm. | 3750 rpm. | 4000 rpm. | 7400 rpm. | 6000 rpm. |
| Maximum speed: | 238 km/h | 185 km/h | 165 km/h | 180 km/h | 264 km/h | 250 km/h |
| Acceleration from 0 to 100 km/h: | 7.0 sec | 13.8 sec | 13.7 sec | 11.4 sec | 5.6 sec | 5.4 sec |
| Torque: | 400 Nm @ 2000-2250 rpm. | 222 Nm @ 4100 rpm. | 200 Nm @ 1750 rpm. | 320 Nm @ 1750 rpm. | 290 Nm/4500-6500 rpm. | 530 Nm @ 2800-4800 rpm. |
| Model Engine: | N47D20 | K9K 892 | R9M | M 273.961 | ||
| Engine position: | Front, longitudinal | Front, transverse | Front, transverse | Front, transverse | Middle, longitudinal | Front, longitudinal |
| Engine displacement: | 1995 cm3 | 2497 cm3 | 1461 cm3 | 1598 cm3 | 2706 cm3 | 5461 cm3 |
| Engine oil capacity: | 5.2 l | 4.5 l | 5.5-6.2 l | 8.5 l | ||
| Coolant: | 7.2 l | 4.5 l | 8.1 l | |||
| Fuel System: | Diesel Commonrail | Multi-point injection | Diesel Commonrail | Diesel Commonrail | Direct injection | Multi-point injection |
| Aspiration / Turbine: | Turbocharger | Turbocharger / Intercooler | ||||
| Position of cylinders: | Inline | V engine | Inline | Inline | Boxer | V engine |
| Valvetrain: | - | DOHC | SOHC | |||
| Number of cylinders: | 4 | 6 | 4 | 4 | 6 | 8 |
| Number of valves per cylinder: | 4 | 4 | 2 | 4 | 4 | 4 |
| Compression ratio: | 16 | 10.4 | 17.6 | 12.5 | 10.7 | |
| Piston Stroke: | 90 mm | 82.8 mm | 80.5 mm | 79.5 mm | ||
| Cylinder Bore: | 84 mm | 80 mm | 76 mm | 80 mm | ||
| Wheel Drive: | Rear wheel drive | Front wheel drive | Front wheel drive | Front wheel drive | Rear wheel drive | Rear wheel drive |
| Number of Gears (automatic transmission): | Xtronic | 7 PDK | 7G-TRONIC | |||
| Number of Gears (manual transmission): | 6 | 5 | 5 | |||
| Length: | 4239 mm | 4890 mm | 4473 mm | 4690 mm | 4380 mm | 5096 mm |
| Width: | 1748 mm | 1900 mm | 1740 mm | 1820-1830 mm | 1801 mm | 1871 mm |
| Width including mirrors: | 1934 mm | 1993 mm | 2120 mm | |||
| Height: | 1421 mm | 1730 mm | 1640 mm | 1700-1730 mm | 1294 mm | 1479 mm |
| Wheelbase: | 2660 mm | 2910 mm | 2905 mm | 2705 mm | 2475 mm | 3035 mm |
| Front track: | 1484 mm | 1625 mm | 1469 mm | 1575-1585 mm | 1600 mm | |
| Rear (Back) track: | 1497 mm | 1600 mm | 1466 mm | 1575-1585 mm | 1606 mm | |
| Ride height(clearance): | 160 mm | 210 mm | ||||
| Approach angle: | 18 ° | |||||
| Departure angle: | 27 ° | |||||
| Ramp angle: | 20 ° | |||||
| Front overhang: | 751 mm | 797 mm | 888 mm | |||
| Rear overhang: | 828 mm | 771 mm | 1173 mm | |||
| Minimum volume of Luggage (trunk): | 330 l | 344 l | 198 l | 550 l | 425 l | 560 l |
| Maximum amount of Luggage (trunk): | 1150 l | 1159 l | 2350 l | 1982 l | ||
| Front suspension: | The depreciated rack | Wishbone | Independent, Spring McPherson, with stabilizer | Independent, spring | ||
| Rear suspension: | The depreciated rack | Helical spring | Multi-link independent | |||
| Max weight: | 1920 kg | 2425 kg | 1870 kg | 2140 kg | 1685 kg | 2560 kg |
| Front brakes: | Ventilated discs | Ventilated discs | Ventilated discs | Ventilated discs | Disc | |
| Rear brakes: | Disc | Drum | Ventilated discs | Ventilated discs | Disc | |
| Kerb Weight: | 1420 kg | 1761 kg | 1255 kg | 1540-1688 kg | 1360 kg | 1880 kg |
| ABS: | yes | yes | yes | yes | yes | |
| Steering type: | Steering rack and pinion | Steering rack and pinion | Steering rack and pinion | Steering rack and pinion | Steering rack and pinion | Steering rack and pinion |
| Power steering: | Hydraulic Steering | Hydraulic Steering | Hydraulic Steering | Electric Steering | ||
| Max. roof load: | 75 kg | 80 kg | 100 kg | |||
| Permitted trailer load with brakes (8%): | 1200 kg | |||||
| Minimum turning circle (turning diameter): | 13 m | 11.25 m | 11.2 m | 11.8 m | ||
| Permitted trailer load with brakes (12%): | 1200 kg | 1300 kg | 1500 kg | |||
| Permitted trailer load without brakes: | 740 kg | 665 kg | 750 kg | |||
| Permitted towbar download: | 75 kg | 75 kg | 75 kg | |||
| Tire size: | 205/50 R17 W | 215/65 R15 | 185/65 R15 | 225/65 R17; 225/60 R18; 225/55 R19 | 255/45 R18 | |
| Wheel rims size: | 7J x 17 | R15 | 6J x 15 | R17; R18; R19 | R18 |